The Stories We Add to Other People’s Words
I like to share things with my kids. I have talked about this before. I will find little uplifting memes, things that I have found helpful, and send them along. I send them to my niece and nephew too. Usually, my niece and nephew appreciate it. They might say thank you, or if something really resonates with them, they will tell me. Less so with my kids. Usually for them it is no reply.
“If thou art pained by any external thing, it is not this thing that disturbs thee, but thy own judgment about it.” – Marcus Aurelius, Meditations 8.47
It is one little way I have of reaching out and saying, “Hey, I care about you. I am thinking about you. I found this useful, and I hope you do too.” But that is not always the way it is received. Sometimes I send something and get a strong disagreement in return, particularly from one of my children. They are not accepting it as I sent it. They are accepting it as something different. They get upset about it, argue about it, become triggered, or criticize me for something I do not think I actually said.
I am getting to the point where I am afraid to send anything, even something I think might be beneficial. We have all experienced trauma. We have all gone through things. These are things I have found helpful in dealing with life, and sharing them felt like one little thing I still had. Now I do not feel like I have that anymore because I never know how it is going to be received. And that makes me not want to reach out as much.
I am trying to maintain some type of relationship, but sometimes it feels as though unless I agree one hundred percent with whatever they believe at the moment, I become the bad guy. I often feel misrepresented, including in things said about me on social media that they apparently do not think I can see. That is really upsetting.
What makes it harder is that I can see the distortion, but they cannot. Everybody else around them seems to see it too. Their family loves them, but their family is also afraid of them. People are afraid that if they say the wrong thing, there will be an explosion of anger. When that happens, it can feel like a nuclear blast. Everyone nearby takes some emotional damage.
“The first qualification for judging any piece of workmanship … is to know what it is—what it was intended to do.” – C. S. Lewis, A Preface to Paradise Lost
For some reason, there seems to be an idea that because they hurt, they have the right to hurt everybody else. Or perhaps because they hurt, everyone else should hurt. Or because they feel the rest of us are not doing enough about their pain, they are going to make sure we feel some of it too. I do not know how to deal with that.
So I keep trying. I keep praying. I hope that eventually there will be some understanding, and maybe a willingness to accept things as they are rather than making them into something they are not. That last part may be the most frustrating for me.
Recently there was a disagreement over a meme. I finally said, “The meme says this exactly.” The response was essentially, “Well, the subtext is…” But sometimes there is no hidden subtext. I certainly didn’t intend any subtext. If I say something costs $1.50, it costs $1.50. Do not tell me that what I really mean is that I am going to charge you more. Do not add baggage to what is actually being said.
Yet that seems to be exactly what happens. Something is said, and then additional meaning is placed behind it. Intentions are assigned. Motives are inferred. Before long, the argument is no longer about what I actually said. It is about what somebody believes I secretly meant.
I just experienced something similar with my mom. She called and said she was hurt by something I had said. Again, the hurt seemed to come from reading something into my words that I did not say and did not intend. That does not mean her feelings are not real. They are. But feelings can be real while the interpretation that produced them is wrong.
I think what we read into another person’s words sometimes tells us as much about what is happening inside our own minds as it does about the person speaking. Of course, recognizing that is difficult because bias is difficult to see from the inside. Biased people rarely recognize their own bias. It takes a special kind of effort to stop, think about what we are saying, and ask, “Am I biased here?” Trust me, I know I am biased too. I do not always see my own biases. I try to find them, because I know they are going to be there. That is one reason I tend to be cautious about the level of certainty I attach to things. You will not often hear me say, “I am one hundred percent certain about this.” I am much more likely to say, “It seems like this,” or, “I do not know, but this is how I think it is.”
I know I could be wrong. I know I could be falling for my own bias. I hope the people around me will tell me when they think that is happening. Hopefully they do it nicely, but I want them to say, “I see what you are saying, but I do not see it that way. I see it this way.” I have friends who do that, why can’t family?
“Anything that can be accomplished with anger can be better done without it.” – Dallas Willard
We disagree from time to time, and that is fine. I take their perspective under advisement. I think about it. I ask whether there is something to what they are saying. Sometimes there is. Sometimes I change my mind. But part of being able to do that is accepting what another person says for what it is. I do not automatically assume malicious intent. I think this is a key.
If someone has a different point of view, I do not necessarily know why they have that point of view. If I really want to understand, that is something I can ask about. But I do not begin by assuming that everybody talking to me is trying to belittle me, insult me, manipulate me, or hurt me. Most of the time, I think most people probably have reasonably good intentions.
I wonder whether some of this has to do with developing an identity as a victim. If I understand myself primarily through the lens of being victimized, then I may begin interpreting everything that happens to me from that vantage point. Other people become oppressors, victimizers, or villains, and I remain the victim. Once that framework is in place, I can see how ordinary disagreements or poorly worded comments might begin to look malicious.
I am not saying that people are never malicious. Of course they are. I am saying that malicious intent should not automatically be our first explanation.
I also become frustrated by the way the word gaslighting sometimes gets used. If I say, “You are assuming malicious intent where none exists,” that is not necessarily gaslighting. I may be wrong about the situation. The other person may be wrong. We may both have parts of the situation wrong. But disagreement over someone’s interpretation is not automatically an attempt to manipulate that person’s perception of reality.
“What hurts this man is not this occurrence itself … but the view he chooses to take of it.” – Epictetus, Enchiridion 16
Sometimes the disagreement really is about the interpretation. And, yes, sometimes I get extremely frustrated. There are moments when part of me wants to say, “I don’t give a fuck about your feelings. The truth is that you are causing the feelings, not me.” That is my frustration talking, of course.
I know that response is not exactly overflowing with empathy. But underneath the frustration is something I think is important. I may be a trigger. Something I say may be a trigger. Something I do may remind you of something painful. Your feelings are real. I should care about them. But there is still another step. At some point, we have to stop, recognize what we are feeling, examine why we are feeling it, and exercise some emotional intelligence and self-control.
That includes me. If I know someone has a particular trigger, I should do what I reasonably can to avoid unnecessarily setting it off. That is part of loving people and having empathy. But I am not always going to know. I cannot anticipate every association, every wound, every interpretation, or every possible meaning somebody might attach to my words. So there has to be some grace on the other side too. There also has to be room to say, “Maybe I interpreted that incorrectly.”
I know how much difference that can make because I have had to learn to do it myself. In psychology, there is a term for part of this; it is called reframing. It means learning to look at a situation through a different interpretive frame rather than simply accepting our first emotional interpretation as the only possible explanation. When I learned this, I had to change the way I looked at things. Not saying I am perfect in this area.
That is one of the things I wish I could somehow give to my kids, but I cannot do it for them. And perhaps that is the hardest realization. I cannot change the way another person thinks. As much as I know and could fix it if they would just listen and do. LOL, I guess I know how God feels.
I can change the way I communicate. I can try to be clearer. I can show more empathy. I can learn where the landmines are and avoid stepping on the ones I know about. I can listen. I can apologize when I really have caused harm. I can examine my own biases. I can ask whether I contributed to the problem. But I cannot control what someone adds to my words after I speak them. So no amount of walking on eggshells will help.
“Men are disturbed not by things, but by the views which they take of things.” – Epictetus, Enchiridion 5
I am hurt too when people automatically assume malicious intent, because if they assumed the best about me instead of the worst, many of these situations probably would not escalate the way they do. That is really what I want for my kids, I want them to have peace. I want them to be able to live in peace with as many people as possible. I want them to know that their family loves them. I want them to realize that they may be missing out on relationships because people, our family especially, have become afraid of saying the wrong thing around them. So they don’t say anything. Then their saying nothing is taken as a slight, indifference, or worse, rejection.
And the tragedy is that they may not even know it. They can’t see it. The narrative they have constructed in their head is one of rejection and victimization. I do not know how to tell them that without producing exactly the explosion I am talking about. So I keep trying. I keep praying. And I keep hoping that one day something changes. I know all things are possible with God. I also know He won’t force a person to change their minds. I can only pray and hope.
Take it as intended, at least until there is a good reason not to. Perhaps that requires a little grace from all of us. The key may already be in our hands, or in our heads, if you prefer. We just have to figure out how to unlock it.
Excerpt
We often react not to what someone actually said, but to what we think they meant. Feelings may be real, but our interpretation can still be wrong. Assuming malicious intent can damage relationships, especially when grace, clarification, and a willingness to question our own biases might have changed everything.
Ἔρεβος



Leave a Reply